Making America Grovel Again
Donald Trump has attempted to whitewash his absolute handover of U.S. foreign policy to the interests and demands of Vladimir Putin by pointing to the latter’s pathetic gesture of releasing an American prisoner who had been held in a Russian jail for four years on charges of — oh, the irony of it all — fighting for Ukraine. As though this release were a grand achievement; as though it were evidence of supreme statesmanship for a president to subject his whole country and all its citizens to the rule of a hostile tyrant in exchange for securing the release of one unjustly held prisoner — as long as he himself, the president, stands to lose nothing he cares about in the deal. We even had the disgraceful spectacle of Trump’s lead capitulator, Steve Witkoff, gushing in person to Putin about his humanitarianism in releasing a prisoner whose last four years were destroyed in a Russian jail thanks to that same humanitarian.
Let us consider this very Trumpian reasoning from another angle, shall we? In this age of self-congratulatory compassion, moral solipsism, and nihilistic relativism, every publicly acceptable response to this news story is forced to begin by granting that the prisoner’s release is an unqualified good for which President Trump may duly take credit. But is this a reasonable view of the situation, and of the price paid?
We may leave aside the immediate feelings of Stephen Hubbard, the newly released prisoner, who must surely be elated to be granted his freedom after years of detention as a political pawn by the world’s longest-ruling and most bloodthirsty dictator. Who, after all — apart from Trump, Tucker Carlson, and Steve Witkoff, apparently — wouldn’t be thrilled to escape from living at the whim and under the absolute control of Vladimir Putin? Nevertheless, I have to ask, if we can just view the matter objectively, rationally, and with principle for a moment, rather than from the understandably confused and basic survivalist perspective of a frightened and desperate political pawn: Would a good man, granted his personal freedom at the price of the surrender of his country to the control of a tyrant, choose his own personal wellbeing over that of his three hundred and fifty million fellow citizens, not to mention potentially the wellbeing of the entire civilized world?
Would a decent man, if given the choice directly, choose to sacrifice the freedom and self-determination of an invaded country (Ukraine in this case) if that sacrifice were the condition of his own release? Would such a man wish to live his remaining days in personal comfort and “freedom” knowing that millions of innocent people lost their freedom, and tens of thousands of them their lives, for the sake of restoring his?
Every prisoner of war who ever tried to withstand the nightmarish fear, to resist the torture, to refuse to sign the confession, or to withhold the secret plans or the whereabouts of his brothers in arms, was acting on the opposite principle, namely that his country’s good, or civilization’s good, was greater than his own — or to put it another way, that his own good was inseparable from the soul’s higher aspirations, such that the causes of freedom and civilization could never be truly detached from any deliberation regarding what was “good for him.”
Did Stephen Hubbard have the capacity to understand, in his plight, that his release was a publicity stunt meant to soften the blow of American sovereignty being delivered into the hands of a Russian dictator? I assume not, and indeed I hope not, for the sake of his future peace of mind. I merely wish to draw attention to the extent to which his release, like so much else being pawned off on Americans in recent days — the violation of sanctions for the sake of a Russian oil deal that is supposedly going to provide Americans “relief at the pumps,” the attempts to frame Volodymyr Zelensky as the main obstacle to peace negotiations, the blatant lies to evade the fact of Russia’s military and intelligence aid to Iran, and all the rest — must be framed, by honest and clear minds, within the context of the grand giveaway of America’s self-determination and geopolitical strength to the will and benefit of an aggressive authoritarian thug who has kidnapped thousands of Ukrainian children, poisoned dozens of political opponents, and shamelessly murdered civilians in untold numbers over his twenty-six years as his long-suffering country’s hope-destroyer-in-chief.
